dimanche 21 octobre 2012

You don't know what love is (Don Raye, 1941)


1°/ Interpretations :

- John Coltrane : youtube link
- Billie Holiday : youtube link
- Nina Simone : youtube link
- Chet Baker : youtube link  + Chet singing : youtube link.


2°/ The grid :
- Part : link missing
- Ballad, tempo 70 bpm.   
- A  A' B A' form.
- We play it using a lightly simplified grid  : on measure 19 we play Eb7 like at measure 18, rather than Eb9sus4 : 

A :
Fm7      / Db9 C7b9 / Fm  C7b9 / Db7     / Gm7b5 C7b9 / Fm6 Ab7 / Db7      / Gm7b5 C7b9 /

A' :
Fm7      / Db9 C7b9 / Fm  C7b9 / Db7     / Gm7b5 C7b9 / Fm6 Ab7 / Db7 C7b9 / Fm6        /

B :
Bbm7 Eb7 / AbMaj7   / Bbm7 Eb7 / AbMaj7  / Dm7    G7  / CMaj7   / Db9      / C7b9       /

A' :
Fm7      / Db9 C7b9 / Fm  C7b9 / Db7     / Gm7b5 C7b9 / Fm6 Ab7 / Db7 C7b9 / Fm6        /



3°/ Analysis & improvisation:
F minor progression with a switch to relative major tone (Ab) leading to a quite odd major tone a whole 3rd away (C) and back to F minor.

    I     /  trII    V  /  I    /  trII  / II     V   /  I     III  /     trII    / II     /
    I     /  trII    V  /  I    /  trII  / II     V   /  I     III  / trII   V   /      I     /
 sw Maj II - V - I   /   % repeat % / sw Maj3rd II - V - I
/     trII    /      V    /
    I     /  trII    V  /  I    /  trII  / II     V   /  I     III  / trII   V   /      I     /

Tonality of F minor :
  • Fm7 = I*
  • Db9 = Tritonic subs of II7 (G7) = 'secondary dominant' relative V of V (C7b9). Q? : can we play II instead at comping? and at soloing?
  • C7b9 = V
  • Gm7b5 =II
  • Fm6 = I*
  • Ab7 = III (?? should not it be Ab+7 ?? is it a tritone of trII ???)
(*) Im6 and Im7 are interchangeable in this context.

Tone switch to Ab Major :
  • Bbm7 Eb7 / AbMaj7   = Ab II-V-I
  • F minor is the minor relative scale of Ab major.

Tone switch to  C Major
:

  • Dm7  G7  / CMaj7    = C  II-V-I
  • The introduction of C II-V-I there is not theoretically obvious. Passing from Ab II-V-I to C II-V-I can be explained this way : 
    • interval of one major third above Ab, à la 'Giant Steps' Coltrane Changes. 
    • Ab is the tritone of D

4°/ Arrangement :

- Theme :
Melody played by wind soloists.
2 first A sections (A and A') are played rubato, that is with elastic harmonic rythm : the combo follows the soloist for changes. If a single note spans for two chords, the soloist underlines the change rythmically by ???
The combo is back on a straight rythm pattern as from the B section.
- Choruses : ??
- Ending : ??


5°/ Solos :

No remark.


6°/ Play-alongs :

 - Band-In-A-Box : link mising.

Interplay (Bill Evans)


1 The grid
- Part : interplay.PNG
- Medium blues, tempo 110 bpm. 
- We play it using a lightly simplified grid  : no Bbm6 on measure 2, Fm6 all the way from measure 1 trhough 3 :

Fm6      / %        / %         / Fm6   F+7b9
Bbm7     / %        / Fm6       / Ab7
Gm7b5    / C7b9     / Fm6 Dm7b5 / CM7   GM7


2. Analysis
Interplay is a blues in F minor.

I        / %        / %         / I     V+ of
IV       / %        / I         / V of
II       / V        / I   VI    / bVI    VMaj


  • F+7b9 = relative dominant of Bbm7, it is a blues cliché. Why aug not 7?
  • Ab7 = tritonic substitute of D7, relative dominant of Cm7b5
  • Gm7b5 / C7b9 / Fm6 = II V I in Fm
  • Last two measures are an odd Fm turnaround ending on VMaj7

3 : Arrangement :

One grid each :
- Intro : bass + guit
- Piano Theme
- Winds theme
- Solos : piano, flute (guitar comping), trumpet (piano comping), guitar.
- 4/4 : 2 or 4 grids. Battery should gently bring back the softer dynamic before the theme.
- Winds Theme
- Piano Theme
- Outro : bass + guit

Finale on the first measure ad lib.


4. Solos 
  • One first possibility is Fm blues all the way through.
  • And of course you can arpeggiate all chords.
  • turnaround : Fm or F7b9  can be used trhough both measures of the turnaround.
  • measure 4 : F+7b9 : whether play :
    • A diminished arpeggio.
    • F alt  = Gb mel.minor.
    • Bb harm.minor (but without actually playing the Bb, in order to preserve the resolution on the next chord Bbm7).
  • Measure 10 : V of minor II-V-I is Valt (Caug/C7b9) : play C altered scale with 9d and 13b, do NOT play 2 or 6.
  • Tonal scales for each chord : ???


5. Play-alongs :
 - Band-In-A-Box : Interplay3.SGU

6. Interpretations :
  • Played in 1962 by the Bill Evans quintet : Youtbe : link